|
Why Puerto Rico Should Not be Left Behind From the
LGBT Debate in the USA
By © Julizzette
Colón-Bilbraut, Esq./Enkidu
Last
time I checked, Puerto Rico was a territory of the United States of
America, governed basically by the same judicial and legal provisions all
50 states are. Puerto Rico is home for more than 4 million American
citizens and among those 4 million American citizens, there are more than
500,000 Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transexual and Transgender citizens who
are in the most part, unaccounted for by local politicians, lawmakers and
by their fellow citizens. I can’t help but wonder, why do LGBT mainland
based organizations leave us behind?
Why aren’t we part of their struggle, which is also our struggle?
I can speculate about the reasons, but to tell you the truth, I really
don’t have an answer. What I can truthfully tell you, is why I believe,
Puerto Rico, should not be left behind from the LGBT debate in the USA.
In
case you don’t already know, please allow me to point out some
historical and political facts about the relationship between the USA and
PR. Puerto Rico became a territory of the United States of America as a
result of the Hispanic-American War of 1898. Spain by means of the Treaty
of Paris, surrendered us as a bounty of war. The USA military took
possession of the Island immediately. In 1917 the USA Congress by means of
the Jones Act, granted the people of Puerto Rico American citizenship; in
1948 the people of Puerto Rico elected their first native (Puerto Rican)
Governor; in 1952 the people of Puerto Rico approved and enacted The
Constitution for the Commonwealth of Puerto Rico, which by the way, has a
broader scope of protection than the USA Constitution, in terms of Due
Process and Equal Protections. Throughout our 107 year relationship,
Puerto Rican soldiers have fought and are currently fighting to preserve
and uphold the liberties and freedom granted by the American Democracy.
Our LGBT soldiers have also to put up with the “Don’t Ask. Don’t Tell” policy. The USA Congress has granted us
a treatment, similar to that of any other state of the union, in terms of
benefits and legislation. We are part of the American judicial system: we
have a District Court for the District of Puerto Rico, which belongs to
the 1st Circuit of the Court of Appeals; our writs for
Certiorari invoking any protection under the USA Constitution or any
federal law are also considered by the USA Supreme Court. DOMA (Defense of
Marriage Act) was ratified by the Puerto Rico legislature in 1998. We have
no Hate Crime or Employment Anti-Discrimination Act. Puerto Ricans
participate in national politics, comprising a delegation in both the
Republican and Democratic Party.
Despite
all of the above, the LGBT community in Puerto Rico is a distant observer
of all active processes taking place in the USA, concerning the struggles
of our fellow community, when it should be otherwise. To begin with, it
would be profitable for mainland based LGBT organizations, to cater to the
Puerto Rican market by including us in their agenda. Contributions would
start to pour in. Strangely enough, —and this is a topic for another
article— but my fellow Puerto Ricans, generally speaking, believe that
whatever comes from outside its territorial boundaries is better than what
is available locally. Another consideration should be the fact that Puerto
Rico has a very large religious (fundamentalist) community who like the
one in the “states”, is every bit right-wing and conservative. This
past elections, they ‘flexed their political muscle’, and managed to
defeat many of the legislators who favored our equality agenda. It’s
just a matter of time, for Puerto Rican fundamentalists and mainland
religious conservatives to find each other and establish financial ties
and discriminatory common goals and struggles. That just scares me to
death!
Hispanics
have become the newest, biggest minority group in the USA. My educated
guess would be that Puerto Ricans are the largest representative group of
said minority. Because of the
‘moral values’ of President Bush, a significant number of Hispanics
voted for a republican president and not a democrat, unlike what they have
consistently done in the past. To say the least, efforts could have been
and can be coordinated so as to have Puerto Ricans living in the Island,
get in touch with their relatives in the USA and talk them into
representing and advancing our cause with their vote. I believe there is a
consensus among the LGBT community that education is fundamental for the
advancement of our rights and issues. Mainland LGBT organizations should
be willing to coordinate and contribute with their expertise and resources
in educating fellow Puerto Ricans about inclusion and tolerance, so we can
as well educate our families in the states.
Trust me. For us, blood is thicker than water. Most important of
all, our LGBT leadership in the island, is small and lacks resources and
funding. Most of us have a full time job to maintain and we do our
activism in our spare time, which is not much. In my case for example, I
am a solo practitioner, and I try to use as much of my time and resources
(through my office), that I can possibly spare. It’s simply not enough.
The
truth of the matter is that EQUALITY is our common beacon. Even though I
speak on my own behalf, I can attest to the fact, that our LGBT community
and leadership is right here, extending its hand, willing to cooperate in
attaining ‘liberty and justice for all.’
Your
comments are welcomed: jcb@enkidumagazine.com.
|